Thorny Question Paper
Every time I think about my relationship with my phone, I am deeply regretful of how dependent it has become. Although I am aware of the negative relationship I have formed with it, my actions do not align with my desire for change. Like myself, many others may find themselves stuck in this loop of wanting to make a change to their relationship with technology, but finding it difficult to do so. This raises the question: Why do people continue to use their devices even if they are aware of their strong attachment and want to make a change? Research suggests that people are unable to diminish their phone use mainly due to it becoming an automatic habit that arises from different cues and pressures, leading it to be out of their control. This deeply ingrained habit then makes it so that negative emotions and attempts at self-regulation often fail to change or override it.
Several studies have identified different cues and pressures that lead to dependence and habitual use of one’s phone. Emanuel et al. (2014) found that college students often develop a strong dependence on their smartphones as a way to relieve negative emotions, maintain a sense of safety or to stay connected with others. In parallel a study by Roffarello & Derussis (2021) explored the reason behind habitual phone use and examined ways to mitigate it through an app based intervention. They found that phone use habits are often triggered by boredom or a need for distraction. Heitmayer & Lahlou (2021) further found that social and professional pressures can lead people to develop automatic phone use behaviors.These findings all demonstrate that there are a multitude of cues and pressures that lead people to forming a habitual pattern of phone use.
A key factor in why people struggle to control their phone usage is the automaticity of this habitual behavior. In a study conducted by Heitmayer & Lahlou (2021) they recorded and later interviewed participants on their smartphone usage, finding that many people are disrupted by their phone due to the development of a strong automatic behavior, and not due to external cues, like receiving a notification. Although many of the participants mentioned they felt they spend too much time on their phone, this could be difficult to change because of how innate the habit had become.(Heitmayer & Lahlou, 2021) Similarly in a survey study conducted by Clements & Boyle (2018) they found that much of the behavioral use of technology is often compulsive and unmanageable, with high habitual use strongly associated with this compulsivity. As demonstrated by these studies many people may struggle to limit their phone usage because it has become a habit completely out of their control.
Due to this habitual behavior operating automatically, efforts to regulate and reduce phone use often fail even when individuals want a change.Ytre-Arne, et al. (2020) found that although people often express strong feelings about using their time more meaningfully, they still recognize how strong of a prevalence their phones have in their daily life. Many participants reported that intent to use their phone as a quick distraction often spiraled into longer, uncontrolled sessions of app scrolling and switching. Attempts to change this behavior through self-regulation often failed as their phone use is a habit deeply ingrained in their daily lives.(Ytre-Arne, et al., 2020) Likewise, Roffarello & Derussis (2021) noted that many of the participants in their study expressed a desire to change their habitual patterns, but had difficulty doing so through self regulation. In alignment with this a study by Lee (2016) found that habitual technology use is closely correlated with a strong intention to continue using it. Additionally they found that many users who have negative emotions towards their device usage such as anger and anxiety did not have any effect on their intention to continue to use their device. Instead it simply alerted them of their habitual device use and only swayed them toward minimizing their intention to use their phone, but did not change their overall habit. (Lee, 2016)
Across these studies, a pattern emerges suggesting that habitual phone use and the lack of control present in this behavior is the leading reason that makes meaningful change challenging. Although these papers sway one in that direction this conclusion can not be drawn quite yet. Although there were many similarities across these six studies many of them share a limitation, their generalizability. These studies all focus on different populations. Two of the studies focused on undergraduate students.( Clement & Boyle, 2018; Emmanuel et al., 2014) Three focused on specific age ranges.( Roffarello & Derussis, 2021;Heitmayer & Lahlou, 2021;Ytre-Arne, et al., 2020) One study focused on adult workers.(Lee, 2016) All studies focused on populations across Europe, Asia and North America. Additionally although most of the studies did mention participants’ negative view of their phone use this was brought up later and not controlled for in their studies. Therefore, in order to find a definitive conclusion to this question more research needs to be conducted that specifically focuses on people like myself, who are very aware of their phone dependence, and want to make a change but are not able to. Although the current body of research does not give a definitive answer it does give insight into a possible answer as to why phone use habits are difficult to change. This research helps demonstrate that awareness may not be enough to lead people to make a change to their relationship with their phone, as there are many cues that underlie habitual phone use and reinforce its automaticity. Overall there are a lot of factors at play when it comes to making a change to one’s behavior.
References
Clements, J. A., & Boyle, R. (2018). Compulsive technology use: Compulsive use of mobile applications. Computers in Human Behavior, 87, 34–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2018.05.018
Emanuel, R., Bell, R., Cotton, C., Craig, J., Drummond, D., Gibbs, S., Harris, A., Harris, M., Hatcher-Vance, C., Jones, S., Lewis, J., Longmire, T., Nash, B., Ryans, T., Tyre, E., Walters, D., & Williams, A. (2014). The truth about smartphone addiction. College Student Journal, 291–297.
Heitmayer, M., & Lahlou, S. (2021). Why are smartphones disruptive? An empirical study of smartphone use in real-life contexts. Computers in Human Behavior, 116, 106637. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2020.106637
Lee, J. (2016). Habit, negative emotions, and intention to continue to use a cell phone. Social Behavior and Personality, 44(10), 1687–1698. http://dx.doi.org/10.2224/sbp.2016.44.10.1687
Roffarello, A. M., & De Russis, L. (2021). Understanding, discovering, and mitigating habitual smartphone use in young adults. ACM Transactions on Interactive Intelligent Systems, 11(2), Article 13. https://doi.org/10.1145/3447991
Ytre-Arne, B., Syvertsen, T., Moe, H., & Karlsen, F. (2020). Temporal ambivalences in smartphone use: Conflicting flows, conflicting responsibilities. New Media & Society, 22(9), 1715–1732. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444820913561

My Journey
Continue exploring my site!